Oversized Comfy Chairs Are Like A Healthy Relationship

An oversized comfy chair is comfy because it gives you enough space to stretch, change shape, move around, and even grow. Traditional chair design often assumes a fairly tidy posture: hips centered, feet down, body facing forward. But when people relax for long periods, they rarely remain symmetrical. We shift weight onto one hip, tuck up a leg, lean into an arm, rotate slightly, curl up, straighten out, then rearrange the whole operation twenty minutes later.

An oversized chair gives you enough unused seat area to keep changing position without leaving the chair. That’s important because comfort isn’t simply a property of cushioning. Remaining in any position for too long can become uncomfortable; being able to redistribute pressure and change joint angles matters too.

So some of the pleasure of an oversized comfy chair comes from something manufacturers can’t photograph very elegantly: the empty space around you is functional.

That apparently wasted extra foot of cushion lets you move. Which also explains why simply making a conventional chair softer doesn’t reproduce the experience. You can add six inches of down to a narrow armchair and produce something wonderfully plush, but you’re still sitting inside a prescribed little rectangle.

The oversized comfy chair gives you somewhere else to go without actually having to get up. And frankly, any piece of furniture that has found a way to provide movement while preserving laziness deserves more respect than it gets.

A Chair That Even A Teamster Can Love

The oversized comfy chair is what happens when furniture stops pretending that adults sit with both feet on the floor. You know the pose. Back straight, knees together, hands resting pleasantly in the lap. Furniture catalogues are full of people sitting like this, usually beside a bowl containing fruit that’s been professionally arranged. I don’t know who these upright people are (neither do I know who professionally arranges fruit, but I want it to be me!) but by eight o’clock in my house, gravity has won: anyone still sitting vertically is either expecting a visitor or waiting for the Pepto to kick in.

Real sitting deteriorates over the course of an evening. First you lean back. Then one foot comes up. Then the other. A cushion gets moved somewhere anatomically useful. Eventually you’re lying diagonally across the chair with a novel balanced against your stomach, wondering whether getting a glass of water is worth completely reorganizing your body.

This is why the oversized chair exists. It isn’t simply a normal chair enlarged by 30 percent. The good ones acknowledge that comfort begins when nobody is telling your limbs where to go. Mega-sized

One and a Half Chairs = Oversized Comfy Chair

Yet whoever first arrived at the proportion was onto something. A loveseat chaise comes with so many strings attached: put a loveseat in a room and two people are theoretically meant to sit on it, which means you’ve sacrificed half your comfort to the possibility of company. An ordinary armchair, meanwhile, gives you exactly enough room to occupy it correctly. The chair-and-a-half provides the useful bit of a loveseat without the social contract.

Take the Crate & Barrel Lounge Deep Chair and a Half. I love how Crate and Barrel measures comfort with a depth gauge. And don’t tell me they’;re not aware it also evokes a well-known phrase involving balls that signifies “fully.” Anyhoosies… At 49 inches wide and 46 inches deep, it’s a substantial piece of furniture, but what I like about it is that the size hasn’t all been squandered on enormous arms. The arms are relatively narrow and square, leaving a broad interior where the actual person (or persons) goes.

That sounds obvious. It isn’t. There are oversized chairs built like medieval fortifications, with two gigantic upholstered ramparts enclosing a seat scarcely wider than economy class. You buy 50 inches of chair and receive 28 inches of sitting. The rest is border security. The Lounge Deep gives the space back to you.

Its seat construction is sensible too: supportive foam softened with fiber and feather-down over springs. That’s approximately the arrangement I want in a chair this indulgent. Feather alone sounds luxurious until you’ve spent six months beating the cushion back into the shape of furniture. Foam alone can have all the yielding charm of a bus station. Put the two together properly and you get the desirable contradiction: a chair that feels soft without behaving soft.

The depth won’t suit everyone. A short person attempting formal upright sitting may require enough loose cushions to open a small branch of Pottery Barn. But formal upright sitting rather misses the point. This is a chair for getting your feet into. If you’re buying one to conduct job interviews, you’ve taken a wrong turn somewhere.

An Oversized Comfortable Chair Needs a Skeleton

There is a widespread belief that the softer a chair is, the more comfortable it must be. This is how people end up purchasing enormous cream-colored marshmallows and discovering three months later that they’re living at the bottom of them. The showroom test encourages bad decisions. You sit down, sink dramatically and think ohhhhh. That noise is apparently worth $1,800. Try staying there for two hours.

A great oversized comfy chair needs some firmness buried beneath the hospitality. The seat should compress and then stop. The back should receive your shoulders without slowly folding around your head. When you stand up, the cushion should eventually remember that it was once rectangular.

This is the unsexy part of comfortable furniture: springs, foam density, webbing, frames. Nobody pours a glass of wine and whispers, “Come over here and feel this excellent suspension system.” Nevertheless, without it your gorgeous chair becomes a bag of upholstery with a person trapped inside.

Or Forget the Skeleton Entirely

At the opposite end of the argument sits—or perhaps slumps—the Lovesac MovieSac, which has decided that the traditional chair contains an unnecessary amount of chair.

No arms. No legs. No rigid back. No recognizable seat. It’s essentially an enormous fabric-covered quantity of shredded foam, roughly four feet across, that waits for you to fall into it and then negotiates the details. This should be awful. Yes somehow It isn’t.

The MovieSac succeeds because it doesn’t make the mistake of pretending to be refined. There is no tasteful wooden base peeking out underneath to reassure your mother. It’s a giant squishy object for watching films, reading, gaming, napping and occasionally sharing with another person if you’re prepared to discover how gravity feels about your relationship.

The shredded foam moves around your body, which makes the MovieSac extraordinarily adaptable. You can punch it, shove it and rearrange it until you’ve created whatever species of chair you require that evening. It’s furniture by geological process.

There are disadvantages. Getting elegantly out of one is impossible. You emerge. If you’re holding a drink, finish it first. And visually, the MovieSac can overwhelm a small room with the cheerful confidence of an indoor boulder.

I wouldn’t put one in a formal sitting room unless I actively disliked the formal sitting room. In a den, bedroom or movie room, however, I completely understand the appeal. The Crate & Barrel chair offers civilization with its tie loosened. The MovieSac has thrown the tie into the ceiling fan. Both are legitimate approaches to Tuesday night.

The Arms Are Going to Become Pillows

If you choose the conventional route, pay attention to the arms. Not how they photograph. Put your head on one. You will eventually do this anyway, so dispense with the dignity while you’re still in the store. An oversized chair with hard, high arms has failed to anticipate its own future. After dinner, when the book starts slipping downward and you’ve read the same paragraph four times, that armrest is becoming a pillow whether the designer intended it or not.

This is one reason I prefer generously padded arms on a serious lounging chair. They make the whole thing feel enclosed. A broad seat by itself is merely a platform; surround it with a substantial back and comfortable arms and you’ve created a small upholstered refuge.

There should also be somewhere to wedge yourself. Corners are underrated in seating. Human beings enjoy corners. We put pillows in them and shoulders against them and somehow become more comfortable than ergonomics diagrams suggest should be possible.

Please Buy a Fabric You Can Touch

Then there’s upholstery, an area in which otherwise rational people lose their minds because they’ve been shown a swatch called Belgian Oat. You’re going to rub your face against this thing. Choose accordingly.

A cozy chair can tolerate some texture and even some visual weight. Chenille, velvet, corduroy, substantial woven fabrics—anything that makes you want to run a hand across it has potential. Leather can be superb, especially once it has stopped looking like it belongs in a lawyer’s waiting room.

What I don’t want is an enormous chair covered in fabric selected primarily because its exact shade of greige coordinates with a ceramic pot containing a dead eucalyptus branch. Comfort deserves better.

And if you have children or animals, don’t buy upholstery that requires everyone to behave differently around the furniture. A chair protected from its own household by blankets, rules and immediate stain-removal interventions is no longer a comfy chair. It’s a hostage situation.

The Best Chair in the House Will Be Stolen

You’ll know you’ve chosen well because the chair will cease to belong to you. This happens gradually. Someone starts reading there. The dog notices. A blanket appears over the back. The side table acquires glasses, a mug and a book with a receipt being used as a bookmark. Visitors arrive and, with infuriating instinct, choose that chair immediately.

Years pass and the cushion softens. The fabric develops a little wear on the arm everybody uses. Perhaps the seat isn’t as magnificently plump as it was on delivery day, but now you know exactly where to sit and exactly where the cushion needs to go behind your shoulder.

At that point, replacing it becomes surprisingly difficult. The new chairs look wonderful in the showroom, standing there with their perfect cushions and their stupid little decorative pillows, but none of them is the chair.

That’s the peculiar excellence of an oversized comfy chair. A dining table can be more beautiful. An Aeron can be more ingenious. Some exquisite mid-century chair can have a better pedigree and a place in the Museum of Modern Art.

But when it’s raining outside, you’ve got nowhere to be, there’s something worth reading on the table and one seat in the room is large enough to climb into rather than merely sit upon, nobody fights over the museum piece. They want the enormous one.

Frequently Asked Questions